Should I hedge? Hedged vs. Unhedged ETFs in Canada

When you look at the TSX composite, you will notice that the financial and energy sectors make up a large percentage of the index. In fact, the financial sector constitutes over 30% and the energy sector almost 15% of the TSX. If you want a heavier weighting in the consumer staples, consumer discretionary, technology, or health care sectors in your portfolio, it almost always means you have to invest outside of the Canadian market. 

For most investors, the easiest way to diversify outside of Canada is utilizing one of the many low-cost index ETFs available. When investing outside of Canada, one of the things to consider is currency exchange rates because they can either work for you or against you. 

Hence, investors must answer this very important question: should you utilize currency-hedged ETFs? Or should you ignore the currency exchange rate risk and go with unhedged ETFs?

Hedged vs. unhedged ETFs, which one should you choose? It’s an important and complicated question. Let’s take a closer look. 

What is currency hedging? 

I’ll be honest. When I first started doing DIY investing, I didn’t understand what currency hedging meant. The term confused me for a very long time. 

What does currency hedging mean exactly? 

Think of currency hedging like buying car or house insurance. You’re buying and paying for the insurance to protect yourself from an unforeseen event that could cause you to lose a lot of money. 

In layman’s terms, currency hedging is a strategy to reduce the effects of currency fluctuations. You’re betting that the foreign currency, usually the US dollar, will weaken against the Canadian dollar. In other words, currency hedging allows you to hold foreign equities without worrying about currency fluctuations and impacting your overall return. 

Say you decide to invest in the broad US equity market and the market returned 15% over the past year. During the same year, the US dollar weakened against the Canadian dollar by 10%. 

If you invested in an unhedged US broad equity market index ETF, you’d only see a return of 5% minus expenses. The overall return is not 15% because the 10% currency fluctuation has eaten into your returns. 

In this scenario, you’d benefit from investing in a hedged US broad equity market index ETF and end up with a return of 15% minus expenses. 

Currency hedging isn’t all sunshine and rainbows though. Just as it can work in your favour, as with the above example, it can also go against you. For example, if the US dollar strengthens against the Canadian dollar by 10% during that same time period, you’d end up with a return of 25% minus expenses with an unhedged ETF but only a return of 5% with a hedged ETF. That’s a significant difference!

How do ETF managers hedge currencies? 

How do ETF managers hedge and manage risk caused by currency fluctuation? Can’t the average investors like you and me do the same, deploy similar strategies, and avoid paying the ETF management fees?

Well, ETF managers hedge by purchasing assets and instruments to offset currency exposure. ETF managers can buy forward contracts by entering into an agreement to exchange a fixed amount of currency at a future date and a specified rate. They can also use future contracts, currency options to hedge against potential currency risks. These assets and instruments are usually adjusted every month to ensure proper exposure to currency exchange rate risks. 

If all that sounds complicated to you, well it is. This is why hedging isn’t something the average investor can easily do. Hedging, as it turns out, is best to leave it to the experts. 

Are currency-hedged ETFs good then? 

Are currency-hedged ETFs good? Should you always invest in currency-hedged ETFs so you don’t have to worry about currency fluctuation and can sleep like a baby?

Well, the answer is complicated. Turns out, there are many factors that investors need to evaluate before deciding whether to use a currency-hedged ETF or not. 

Before we go through these reasons, let’s take a look at the pros and cons of currency-hedged ETFs.

Pros of currency-hedged ETFs

The biggest advantage of currency-hedged ETFs is that you are protecting yourself from any unforeseen (major) currency fluctuation. Essentially, what you see is what you get – you get the true value of the underlying holdings without having to worry about currency exchange rates. This is one of the advantages of CRD’s.

For many investors, this can provide peace of mind and simplify investing in foreign markets.  

Cons of currency-hedged ETFs 

As you can imagine, there’s a cost associated with buying and selling forward and future contracts, options, and other derivatives to offset currency exposure. As a result, currency-hedged ETFs typically have higher management fees compared to their unhedged counterparts.

For example, VSP, the CAD-hedged Vanguard S&P 500 index ETF, has an MER of 0.09%. Meanwhile, its unhedged counterpart, VFV, has an MER of 0.08%. 

Even if management fees are the same between hedged and unhedged ETFs, there are potential hidden costs like higher turnover rates. 

For example, even though the hedged and unhedged Vanguard US Total Market ETFs, VUS and VUN, have the same MER, VUS, the hedged version, has a portfolio turnover rate of 23.38% while VUN the unhedged version only has a portfolio turnover rate of 8.31%. Higher turnover rates typically mean more transaction costs which can lead to lower returns in the long run. 

Furthermore, currency hedging doesn’t always work for you. When the currency fluctuation goes the other way, currency hedging can lead to a lower return. So be careful when people claim that currency hedging will eliminate all currency risks and that you should ALWAYS invest in currency-hedged products! In my opinion, when it comes to investing, there’s no such thing as ‘ALWAYS.”

Why invest in currency-hedged ETFs? 

Given the pros and cons, who is best suited to invest in currency-hedged ETFs? As it turns out, it depends on your risk tolerance and your investment timeline. Here are a few reasons why you’d invest in currency-hedged ETFs.

1. Your investment timeline is short

If we look at the US dollar and Canadian dollar, the all time high was 1.600 in January 2002 and an all time low of 0.948 in October 1959. Over the last 30 years, the historical average has been 1.243

As of writing, the exchange rate is 1.275 which is stronger than the 30-year historical average.  But only slightly! This means there’s a decent chance the US dollar will weaken against the Canadian dollar. However, there are far too many geo-political and geo-economic factors that could possibly arise that no one can accurately predict which way the exchange rate will go in the near, and certainly, in the more distant, future.

If your investment timeline is short, you probably want to protect yourself from the potential weakening of the US dollar. Therefore, it may make sense to pay the extra management fees and use currency-hedged ETFs to smooth out currency fluctuations. On the other hand, if you have a longer investing time horizon, it is probably wise not to go with the hedged option. 

2. If you hold a large percentage of foreign equities

If your portfolio is largely allocated to markets outside of Canada, fluctuation in foreign exchange rates can quickly decrease your returns. Using currency-hedged ETFs is a simple way to potentially lock in your returns and not worry about the inverse effects of adverse currency fluctuation.  

3. You have low risk tolerance

If you are risk averse, currency hedging can potentially reduce the volatility caused by currency exchange rates. By removing currency exchange rates out of the equation, it’s one less thing to worry about for risk averse investors, allowing them to sleep better at night. 

Why invest in unhedged ETFs 

On the flip side, there are many reasons why one may want to consider investing in unhedged ETFs. 

1. A longer investment timeline

Since exchange rates typically settle close to the historical average over the long term and things eventually even out, if you have a longer investment timeline, it doesn’t make sense to pay the extra fees for no real gains in the long term. 

This concept is similar to time in the market rather than timing the market. Over the long term, noises like currency fluctuations will have minor effects on the overall performance of the equity markets. 

2. You don’t want to pay the extra fees 

There have been several studies suggesting that Canadians are wasting billions of dollars on currency-hedged ETFs. I happen to agree with these studies. For most investors that invest for the long term, you will be paying extra fees for minimal gains.

It is more straightforward to save those extra fees and invest in simple unhedged ETFs.  

3. You want to keep your investments simple. 

Long time readers will know that I’m a believer in keeping your investments simple and easy to understand. So utilizing strategies like covered calls, put options, or future contracts for potential short term protection against currency fluctuations makes very little sense to me.

Should I hedge or not? Hedged vs. Unhedged ETFs in Canada

We come to the million dollar question – to hedge or not to hedge?

Well, changes in currency exchange rates can be a problem if you’re investing for the short term. For investors with a short investment timeline, I believe it might make sense to pay extra fees and invest in currency-hedged ETFs. 

Having said that, one must remember that currency hedging works best when the US dollar or other foreign currency is weakening compared to the Canadian dollar (i.e. the Canadian dollar is getting stronger). So if the US dollar is getting stronger, hedging can certainly work against you.

As you can see from the table below, it appears that the currency-hedged ETFs have performed slightly better over the past year. But since the crude oil price was on a roll the past year which helped to strengthen the Canadian dollar, it was more favourable to utilize the currency-hedging strategy. 

ETFsTicker1 Year Return
Vanguard US Total Market ETF (CAD-Hedged)VUX+17.66%
Vanguard US Total Market ETFVUN+17.35%
Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (CAD-hedged)VSP+22.56%
Vanguard S&P 500 ETFVFV+22.23%
Vanguard US dividend appreciation index ETF (CAD-hedged)VGH+19.64%
Vanguard US dividend appreciation index ETF VGG+19.42%

However, since predicting currency movements and trends is nearly impossible, one has to ask if hedging provides any real benefits over the long term. In fact, if we look at the 5-year return of the same hedged vs. unhedged ETFs you’ll notice that unhedged ETFs have all outperformed their hedged counterparts.

ETFsTicker5 Year Return
Vanguard US Total Market ETF (CAD-Hedged)VUX+14.28%
Vanguard US Total Market ETFVUN+18.05%
Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (CAD-hedged)VSP+15.05%
Vanguard S&P 500 ETFVFV+15.79%
Vanguard US dividend appreciation index ETF (CAD-hedged)VGH+13.78%
Vanguard US dividend appreciation index ETF VGG+14.44%

So what’s better? Hedging vs. unhedged? For most investors, you can reduce the need to hedge by simply investing for the long term and having global exposure in your portfolio. This can easily be done by investing in a global index ETF, like XAW or VXC or even one of the all-in-one ETFs

By diversifying your investments through time and geography, you can save yourself some money. Keep your investments simple and easy to understand. That’s the best advice I can give to readers. 

Share on:
.

10 thoughts on “Should I hedge? Hedged vs. Unhedged ETFs in Canada”

  1. In the example above, you said: “For example, if the US dollar strengthens against the Canadian dollar by 10% during that same time period, you’d end up with a return of 25% minus expenses with an unhedged ETF but only a return of 5% with a hedged ETF. That’s a significant difference!”

    But – unless I’m confused – I think you meant that the hedged ETF would return 15%.

    Reply
  2. Whether to hedge or not hedge is a debate and there is no easy answer. One justification to avoid hedging could be high fees assuming returns are more or less similar. However, in some cases where hedging protects or gives smoother returns it may work out well.
    Mutual funds and fund houses provide a hedged option for investors esp. In my opinion this is just like additional options or features funds want to provide to address concern regarding currency fluctuations. For me personally I dont have a preference for hedged fund. Keeping my views aside its practically not feasible for individual investors to do own hedging, so to meet this requirement if one goes for a hedged fund it makes sense because funds have access to currency market volumes, low transaction fees, etc.

    Reply
  3. Thanks for this article, Bob. Clear and straight forward, as always.

    Note for you and your readers: I wanted to buy the unhedged version of QQC. The information on Scotia Itrade AND TD were both backward. They both, incorrectly, have QQC as the hedged version and QQC.F as the UNhedged version. The error was confirmed to me by Invesco in an email. I pointed it out a few months ago to TD and Scotia and neither have changed their web site info.
    It’s a good example of buyer beware.

    ps. Nice photo at the top of the article!

    Reply
  4. I don’t do hedging.
    It’s good that we can have separate US and C $ brokerage accounts.
    I’m roughly 50% Canadian stocks and 50% US, EU, Australia individual stocks through my US account and US ADR’s. My dividends are paid in US$ and just stay long term in that account ready to reinvest .
    Long term I see no threat to US hegemony for decades and the US$ as the world reserve currency. Just look at the unstable, brutal dictatorships with manufactured accounting that compete with the US internationally.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.